It was in the wake of the BHS scandal in 2016 that UK Prime Minister Theresa May announced a major reform of UK corporate governance. But in 2017, one of the greatest scandals in British history, the Carillion collapse, occurred. The UK Financial Reporting Council published a revision to the Corporate Governance Code on Dec. 5, 2017, but there is now considerable debate over whether reform measures are sufficient.
TIMELINE FOR CORPORATE GOVERNANCE SCANDALS IN THE UK
1991 – Polly Peck collapses with £1.3 billion (US$1.85 billion) in debts
1991 – Robert Maxwell plunders £443 million (US$628 million) from Mirror Group pension fund
2003 – Sea-Land Services pension fund shows 50 per cent deficit
2005 – MG Rover announces insolvency, 30,000 jobs lost
2008 – Northern Rock collapses with £3 billion (US$4.25 billion) deficit
2008 – Royal Bank of Scotland collapses needing £12 billion (US$16.9 billion), is nationalised
2012 – Libor scandal shows rate-fixing at a number of major UK banks
2014 – Tesco overstates profit by £263 million (US$373 million)
2016 – BHS closes with £571 million (US$808 million) hole in pension fund
In the midst of the UK government’s efforts to reform corporate governance, the Jan. 14 collapse of outsourcing firm Carillion has again shone a spotlight on gaps in the country’s regime.
“The UK Government and Parliament launched two public consultations on corporate governance in 2016 and 2017 which included questions on the obligations of corporate directors and systems of executive remuneration, as well as on the role of workers to counter-balance short-term thinking. Beyond the present damage control and depuration of responsibilities, it is imperative that UK legislators proceed with the revision of the corporate governance framework in order to avoid yet another corporate implosion,” complains Filip Gregor, Head of Responsible Companies at Frank Bold, in a recent report.
Carillion’s unpaid debts come to about £750 million (US$1.06 million), and the UK taxpayer will wind up on the hook for a large part of that – or more than £250 million (US$355.97 million), according to some current estimates.
The scandal has exacerbated the ongoing debate about the future of corporate governance in the country.
“How is it that so many warning signs were ignored by the company and the government? What were the Carillion board and senior management doing to address the spiralling problems at the company? Why are the regulatory bodies stepping in only after Carillion’s collapse?” asks MP Rachel Reeves, who chairs the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Committee in the UK Parliament.
On Dec. 5, 2017, the UK Financial Reporting Council published a new version of the Corporate Governance Code, one that changes somewhat the overall orientation of the regulations. A consultation is underway, but the tenor of the debate is growing stronger.
“The revised Code emphasises the value of good corporate governance to the sustainable growth of a company and encourages policies and practices that generate value for shareholders and aim to benefit society. There is a new focus on stakeholders, integrity and corporate culture, diversity and how the overall governance of the company contributes to its long-term success,” explains David Crone of the London-based law firm Womble Bond Dickinson.
The new code is shorter, sharper and better-focused on the long term, most observers agree.
“But many feel that it does not have the bite required – it would not have saved Carillion, although poor corporate governance is clearly what led to Carillion’s failure,” comments Sophie Brookes of the London-based law firm Gateley. “The proposed new code will only prove effective if shareholders and investors are prepared to step in and hold boards to account.”
Tim Ward, chief executive of the Quoted Companies Alliance, also feels that there is insufficient transparency at most companies, just like at Carillion. He says, in a note: “At another level we are not seeing strong increases in the level of disclosures relating to Audit Committee and Remuneration Committee reports. For instance only a third of companies include details of significant issues considered by the Audit Committee in relation to financial statements and how these issues were addressed. So there is more to be done by companies.”
There is also some frustration, in the UK business community, that the government’s proposals were not implemented in the latest version of the code.
“So far as listed companies are concerned, the proposals do not go as far as some had thought they might. While publishing the ratio between CEO pay and their employees’ pay looks set to become mandatory for these companies, proposals to hold annual binding shareholder votes on executive pay and to require employee representation on boards are not being taken forward,” comments David Collins of the Denton’s law firm.
Ward proposes that dialogue with shareholders is the key to making corporate governance work in the UK.
“Once good corporate governance has been put into place, and the board are confident that they have done only what is needed to create long-term value, then the board should ensure that in the relevant section of their website there is an index showing where each disclosure required by the QCA Code can be found. Each box needs to be ticked to help shareholders find what they are looking for,” he continues. UK Prime Minister Theresa May reacted to the Carillion scandal with a call for strengthening corporate governance: “Too often we’ve seen top executives reaping big bonuses for recklessly putting short-term profit ahead of long-term success. Our best businesses know that is not a responsible way to run a business and those who do so will be forced to explain themselves,” she said.
But this rhetoric is not being put sufficiently into practice in the current proposed reform of corporate governance, many observers feel, and the debate over the reforms is likely to be serious.
Diligent Boards keeps directors up-to-date
To keep up with all the information regarding corporate governance in the UK, Diligent Boards keeps directors up-to-date. Diligent Boards moves all of the agendas, documents, annotations and discussions of board meetings online into one intuitive, secure portal. The platform goes beyond digital board books to manage the full scope of a board’s moving parts — committees, contacts, voting, reporting and more.
With Diligent Boards, on-the-go directors will have more than iPad board meeting software at their fingertips. From a single sign-on (even for those who sit on multiple boards), they’ll be able to work across devices (with real-time syncing) to: stay current with committee meetings and materials; communicate and annotate documents in tandem with other users and get notifications for updates; easily search archives and board resources; complete questionnaires; and submit their votes and signatures any time of the day or night, from anywhere in the world, from their smartphone, tablet or laptop.
December 28, 2020
What Role Does the Board Play in Business Continuity Planning?
Continuing in the face of adversity has been the dominant theme of the past year. When the scale of disruption caused by COVID-19 became clear, businesses worldwide were forced to adapt rapidly to the restrictions that came into force overnight. While many organisations have business continuity plans designed to keep…
December 21, 2020
Business Continuity Plan Maintenance: A Step-by-Step Guide
A business continuity plan (BCP) is a living, evolving document. Designed to be activated when unplanned disruption strikes, it must be flexible enough to guide actions regardless of the specifics of the situation. In a fast-changing environment, business continuity plan maintenance is an essential part of the business continuity programme…
December 8, 2020
Board Meeting Minutes Best Practices and Guidelines
Guidelines for Board Meeting Minute Taking In order to keep the courtroom from invading the boardroom, the most basic rule is, “saying less is often better,” warns the London-based law firm Bricker & Eckler in a recent note. “Today’s business climate places heightened…